Friday, January 30, 2009

Five reasons that Calvin was a postmodernist - well not quite

  1. Calvin thought author's intentions were not decisive for interpretation, though not irrelevant. You can't understand biblical prophecy if you are wedded to author's intentions! In fact, it was the Enlightenment that was obsessed with origins and psychological states, not the Reformation. The text is to be understood with reference to its self, primarily.
  2. Calvin recognised that texts produced a multiplicity of possible meanings depending on context and purpose - because he believed that the text was speaking to us today, and had spoken to people in the past. The text has a tradition of interpretation that is not irrelevant to understanding it.
  3. But Calvin's not an allegorist - he believes in history, of which we are a part. He doesn't seek 'eternal spiritual truths' from the text. Rather, he is aware of its time-boundedness. So, NARRATIVE is really important for him
  4. He thinks hermeneutics has a context - ie, it serves an interpretative community. 'Who is this for?' is a question that really matters for the interpreter.
  5. He was French -so must have been a postmodern!

4 comments:

Chris said...

i've been waiting to hear this for some time. who writes helpfully on this? or should one just read the institutes?

Ricardo said...

Glad to read you Michel. I enjoy your postings on Calvin. You can be sure that I will share your post modern understanding on Calving here in France. Oddly enough the 5th point may be "inexact". French find boring Postmodernism. It is limited to very intelectual circles. And Christians show (over all calvinist... 'French reformed churches')a very little interest. Most of the Time Postmodernism is associated to an art movement, or just Nihilism.
Even the title of my blog here in France is more a provocation than an statement.

By the way in my blog there is an article written by an American who lives in France "Emerging in France" who experienced same thing.
But I agree with you. And it makes me feel less lonely. Calvin could be seen as a Post modernist of his time. He questioned all meaning found before. He re-used humanistic tools to re read the message and to make it to speak to his generation. He searched for God intentions in the Text at the same time that he accepted his limits to even grasp it.
Nice to read you.

cyberpastor said...

Is it worth mentioning that Calvin as a humanist was "deconstructing" medieval exegetical practices?

Ricardo said...

I just could not resist, I copied your post on my blog with some of my thoughts.

Hope you don't mind