
The recently deceased pragmatist liberal Richard Rorty, in his key text Contigency Irony and Solidarity makes the fascinating observation that for 'ironists' - by which he means people who deny that there is any metaphysical referent to our language and that we ought always be aware of that as we use grand sounding words - for ironists, literary critics are 'moral advisors', not metaphysicians.
As he writes:
literary criticism does for ironists what the search for universal moral principles is supposed to do for metaphysicians. p. 80
Literary critics, you see, engage in the placing of books into traditions of books. Their business is not absolute claims, but relative ones: relating books to other books. Literary critics have basically read alot, and so are less likely to get sucked in by any one book. The critic's job goes well beyond the bounds of mere literary criticism, of course:
...the critic is now expected to facilitate moral reflection by suggesting revisions in the cann of moral exemplars and advisers, and suggesting ways in which the tensions within this canon may be eased - or, where necessary, sharpened. p. 82
4 comments:
Hi Michael!
I was recently on the phone to my mother, who had (I'm never sure how to delineate days and things, when they're in Australia a day ahead and whatnot) not so long before that with my father entertained your parents for lunch, and greatly enjoyed their company.
Your Richard Rorty quotes are rather thought provoking. Perspective makes such a difference to what we see or don't see, doesn't it?
Hope Catherine and the children survived your absence. Cambridge is where we lived as children, as Dad studied at Ridley Hall. I love it!
Cheers,
Meg
Michael,
I still think Vanhoozer is the best way to get into POMO literary questions. On another note, are you going to the Edinburgh Dogmatics conference in August?
Hmm. Vanhoozer's book 'Is there are meaning in this text?' was a bit clunky for mine... I am not sure he really scored big hits against the idea of author's intentions for example.
The Edinburgh conference looks great: alas, it also clashes with a family holiday. Heard your name warmly mentioned at the Tyndale Conference recently.
hey Michael-
just spent the week with susie fletcher (from your church??)- said she knew you- thought of you guys and wanted to say hi!
Liz
Post a Comment