Sunday, July 15, 2007

Update

The view from my room at Nuneham College, Cambridge.

Well it has been a slower period than normal on what my sister affectionately calls 'the most boring blog in the world.' Not that I'm sensitive...


Chiefly, the reason is that my HP/Compaq laptop has given up the ghost, and it has taken the Uni computer dudes a few days to decide this. This is the longest I have ever owned a single laptop: others have been lost to lightening strike, theft, water spillage (what idiot left a paper cup of water on the computer desk at Moore College), and virus. I would love your help on a replacement: at the moment I am favouring a Toshiba Satellite Pro.
Cambridge was excellent: I went to a Symposium on Oliver O'Donovan's Ways of Judgment which is proving to be a re-readable book - which in a world of many great books is high praise. Trouble with the English in formats like this is that they are too polite, and so it is hard to tell when they are actually having an intellectual disagreement. Jonathan Chaplin, Nigel Biggar and Ben Quash gave papers, and O'Donovan responded to each. He is a very fine and engaging speaker, and concedes very little!
The Tyndale Conference followed: this was more of a mish-mash of issues and papers. We heard some very interesting stuff on Islam, and also from David Ford (Prof at Cambridge) on 'Scriptural Reasoning'. He has a new book out called 'Christian Wisdom' which looks enticing. Basically, he is suggesting that inter-faith dialogue (and ecumenical dialogue) take place on the basis of reading one another's scriptures. This prevents an annoying liberal consensus having to be established first (WCOC style). Brian Brock gave a great paper on Genesis 1-4 and ethics. We heard some other papers on politics that made me feel more and more that Christendom wasn't so bad, crusades and what-not notwithstanding. Whenever I hear a Christendom-basher make huge sweeping statements about some fourteen centuries of Church-state relations - as is currently the fashion in Hauerwas-dominated circles - it makes my toes curl. I am becoming more grumpily conservative in me old age...
I also went to one of the Biblical Theology papers given by Brian Rosner. What was fascinating for me is that I realised that there is a HUGE chasm between the methods of biblical studies scholars and those involved in doctrine and ethics. And it seems to me that there is not a great deal of mutually respectful conversation going on between the two...
Since then: I have been reading Barth's Dogmatics II.i, one of the must-read volumes. His review of the Supralapsarian-Infralapsarian controversy is fascinating... though you can see how he is introducing his own position as the only alternative through his account.
I should also report that I have an almost complete first draft of my thesis. Blogging has not hindered but rather helped this! Having had a couple of readers review parts of it, I am encouraged to do a lot better of course. But at least I am getting better at answering that 'what is your thesis about' question...

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

Go MAC Ibook! You will never look back again! As you are a student they will give you a 20% discount too!

Once one becomes a Mac user, you will always want to stay one! They are the Thomas Aquinas' of the computer world!!!

This is a great opportunity for you to go MAC!

Clare said...

I agree with Antopodean. You should consider getting the new Macbook (even a macbook pro). I'm assuming you have Windows based software that you would still like to use. That's ok - you can still install a version of Windows on the new macs.

Personally, I'm a convert from Windows to MAC, but I still need to run some Windows only applications from Windows.

Paul said...

Yeah, the hard drive seized up and had to be binned on my year old MacBook last week... awesome (they did however allow me a special extension of my one year warranty by nine days so I could get it fixed for free... so they are in my good books and bad books simultaneously, as I try to recover my professional credibility after complete machine failure...

Martin Kemp said...

Stay away from Mac's. Beauty is fleeting, and charm is deceptive.

What was fascinating for me is that I realised that there is a HUGE chasm between the methods of biblical studies scholars and those involved in doctrine and ethics.

What differences did you notice?

michael jensen said...

Yes, my experience has been that Macs have been far more unreliable than PCs. Just my experience.

It seems to me, that in conservative Biblical Studies a kind of word-study approach still predominates. Whereas, in doctrine and ethics, it's about the concepts baby. I could say more.

Jon said...

Stay PC - Mac users try to be cooler than they in fact are - just shows that inside they are dissatified with the looks God gave them so they make up other ways.

Barth II.1 is good - O'Donovan one of the best speakers I heard this year

Martin Kemp said...

I could say more.

Go on...

Anonymous said...

I've been reading The Ways of Judgment recently and finding it incredibly profound. I'd be really interested to know what those at the symposium addressed in the text.

I'm keen to explore some of the more philosophical aspects myself, especially the concept of communication as the basic category of social theory. I'm toying with the idea of writing a couple of essays on this stuff, trying to mediate it to a philosophical audience.

Anonymous said...

Sounds like you will stay PC- that's OK! The majority of the world uses PC.

This is especially for all you MAC users out there- I have never ever ever had any problems with my MAC.Yet it is still a man-made machine so I guess problems can happen.

My workplace just went from MAC to PC and I must admit I have experienced "PC Trauma". The simplest thing that one could do on a MAC, one nows has to "FIND" it hidden behind all this other stuff...Computer life is no longer (at work) as straightforward as it used to be. Mind you, using a MAC prepared my brain for navigating a PC and trying to work out the simplest functions.

By the way MPJ, I do agree with you in regards to the 'word studies' thing. In my thesis I had to say that doing word studies doesn't define or give the full meaning to the theological issue I am researching.

Word studies although helpful can/ or may lead to unhelpful reductionism.


All the best with your new PC!!! :)

Anonymous said...

BTW MPJ as you come from Sydney, I thought you would like to know that the weather has been soo cold, that this morning my car was covered in ice (frost). I have never experienced that before, ice covering my car where I live (I live in the southern suburbs) not west (like Liverpool etc). The temps out in the western suburbs have been 0 degrees C & below. It must have been below 5 C this morning. It was definitely freezing walking to the train station.

Anonymous said...

It wasn't just "ice" or Frost, it was thickly coating my car!! Amazing!!

byron smith said...

Mmm, mac: style over substance.

Mmm, PC: neither style nor substance.